posted 04-30-2004 03:54 AM
We normaly do not e-mail our answers, because others would like to read them too. And if we post it here, it is possible to correct them if something is wrong or missunderstood...From my point of view, your question should be answered different for different kingdoms/countries. In the medieval holy roman empire (including what today is Germany, Switzerland, northern Italy, Austria and also parts of France, Polonia, the Czech Rep. and Hungary), the right to build castles was a royal one. But only in theory. Already in the 12th century, noblemen started to build castles without the expilicit allowance of the king, esp. the earls, counts and bishops. During the 13th century, it became even worse because there as no king that was realy accepted (esp. during the Interregnum 1254-1273)...
But it is known from many cases what happend to nobleman who built a castle without asking the next mightier man in his area: Documents were released that told the builder to deconstruct the castle, and if he didn't, the bishop, earl or king would send an army to do it. Which happend many times. The nobleman then could losse not only his castle, but also his other goods, lands and rights.